| Platinum | Il Paesano Pizzeria & Restaurant |
| Platinum | Pizzeria Via Napoli |
| Gold | ViBo |
| Silver | Tre Rose Bakery |
| Bronze | 850 Degrees Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Eden Trattoria |
| Top Pick | La Vecchia Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mama Martinos |
| Top Pick | Remo's Place |
| Top Pick | Sanremo Bakery |